Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

This decadent Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie combines creamy peanut butter filling with sweet whipped topping and crunchy peanut butter crumbles for a dessert that feels both homey and special. The contrast between the silky filling and the textural crumbles creates an irresistible treat that has become a staple at my family gatherings.

I first made this pie for my mother-in-law who adores anything with peanut butter. The look on her face when she took that first bite told me this recipe would become part of our family tradition. Now it makes an appearance at nearly every holiday meal.

Ingredients

• Prebaked 9-inch pie crust: Provides the perfect foundation for this creamy dessert. Store-bought works perfectly fine if you're short on time.
• Powdered sugar: Creates the perfect sweetness and texture for the crumbles. Its fine texture incorporates seamlessly.
• Creamy peanut butter: Forms the heart of this pie. Choose a quality brand like Jif or Skippy for the best flavor and texture.
• Instant vanilla pudding mix: Helps the filling set properly. The vanilla flavor complements the peanut butter beautifully.
• Milk: Activates the pudding mix. Whole milk creates the richest texture but 2% works well too.
• Whipped cream or Cool Whip: Adds lightness to both the filling and topping. Fresh whipped cream tastes best but Cool Whip offers convenience.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Create Peanut Butter Crumbles:

Combine powdered sugar and peanut butter in a small bowl using a fork. Work the ingredients together until they form small pea-sized clusters with a crumbly texture. The mixture should hold its shape when pressed but still break apart easily. Set aside half for the final decoration.

Mix The Filling Base:

Whisk together vanilla pudding mix, milk, and peanut butter for a full 2 minutes until completely smooth. The mixture will thicken considerably as you whisk. Make sure to scrape the sides of the bowl to incorporate all the peanut butter for a uniform consistency.

Add Lightness To The Filling:

Gently fold in whipped cream using a rubber spatula with a light hand. Cut through the center of the mixture and fold the bottom over the top in a figure-eight motion. Continue until fully incorporated but still fluffy. The filling should be light but hold its shape.

Layer The Components:

Sprinkle half the peanut butter crumbles evenly across the bottom of your prebaked crust. Pour the filling over them and smooth with a spatula. The crumbles will provide a delightful textural contrast in each bite.

Top And Chill:

Cover the entire pie with whipped cream or Cool Whip, creating decorative swirls if desired. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours to allow the filling to set completely. Just before serving, sprinkle the remaining crumbles over the top for visual appeal and extra crunch.

Pin it

The secret to this pie's incredible texture lies in those peanut butter crumbles. I discovered them while watching an Amish baker at our local farmers market. She explained that the contrasting textures are what make traditional Amish desserts so memorable. I've never made this pie without someone asking for the recipe afterward.

Choosing The Right Peanut Butter

Commercial creamy peanut butter works better than natural versions for this recipe. Natural peanut butter often separates and can create an oily filling. Brands like Jif, Skippy, or Peter Pan provide the right consistency and sweetness level. If you prefer a more pronounced peanut flavor, try using a combination of regular peanut butter with 2 tablespoons of peanut butter powder mixed in.

Make It Your Own

While the traditional recipe is perfect as is, you can customize this pie in several ways. Add a layer of thinly sliced bananas between the crumbles and filling for a peanut butter banana cream version. Drizzle chocolate sauce over the top before adding the final crumbles for a peanut butter cup variation. For added decadence, mix mini chocolate chips into the filling or sprinkle them on top with the reserved crumbles.

Serving Suggestions

This pie pairs beautifully with a cup of strong coffee or cold milk. For an extra special presentation, serve each slice with a small scoop of chocolate ice cream on the side. The contrast between the cold ice cream and the creamy pie creates a wonderful taste experience. If serving at a gathering, consider making mini versions in a muffin tin with cookie crumb crusts for a delightful individual dessert option.

Pin it

This pie is a simple yet impressive dessert sure to delight any peanut butter lover.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use homemade pie crust for this dessert?

Yes, a homemade pie crust can be used for a more personal touch, but store-bought options work equally well.

→ What type of peanut butter works best?

Use creamy peanut butter as it blends smoothly into the filling and crumbles, ensuring a perfect texture.

→ Can I substitute Cool Whip with homemade whipped cream?

Absolutely! Whipped cream made from scratch adds a fresh, rich flavor and works well in this pie.

→ How long should the pie be chilled before serving?

Refrigerate the pie for at least 2 hours to allow the filling to set properly and ensure clean slices.

→ Can I make the pie in advance?

Yes, this pie can be made a day ahead. Just store it covered in the refrigerator to maintain freshness.

→ What can I use instead of powdered sugar in the crumbles?

You can use finely blended granulated sugar as a substitute, though the texture may vary slightly.